Here is a link to my Sunday column. The full text runs below: The Raiders, who open at home today against the Bengals, did right to sign Aldon Smith to a one-year deal. Oh, that’s such a tepid, cautious statement. The Raiders didn’t only do right. The Raiders did brilliant. Before you point out that I recently praised the 49ers for dumping Smith after yet more off-field problems, yes, I praised the 49ers for dumping Smith. I plead guilty to… Read More »
A Press Democrat Blog
Lowell Cohn's pertinent and impertinent take on sports
Here is a link to my Sunday column about Aldon Smith. The full text runs below: The 49ers are struggling to regain the moral high ground. Sadly, they surrendered it a while back. Everyone knows that. But what they did Friday — they booted Aldon Smith out the door — is a necessary first step. No matter what anyone says, the 49ers did the right and proper thing releasing Smith. Although they could — probably should — have deleted him… Read More »
Lots of people are dumping on Aldon Smith right now, saying he’s a bad guy and the Niners need to dump him. Maybe that’s true and maybe that’s what will happen. But be cautious. We know very little about what he did and said at LAX today. As far as I know he’s not been arrested. Has he? I’m reading he said he had a bomb. Is that a fact? Did he literally say “I have a bomb?” Or did… Read More »
Sometimes fans can be hypocrites. So many fans have supported Aldon Smith and gushed with empathy for him. This is a guy who shot off illegal guns and got drunk and drove into a tree. OK, fine show sympathy. Some of the same fans are down on Jonathan Martin, call him a Mama’s boy, a spoiled Stanford kid. Martin did nothing wrong, didn’t break the law. He got bullied and told about it. Somehow that makes him the villain, makes… Read More »
There has been stuff on the internet that Jim Harbaugh questioned the motives of anyone who disagreed with him about playing Aldon Smith last Sunday. I, of course, disagreed with him about playing Smith. Anyway, Harbaugh made his remarks this morning on radio. I listened to the broadcast and, as far as I could discern, he did not say what he’s reputed to have said. To the best of my hearing — not so good, by the way — he… Read More »
I guess I’m argumentative this morning, so please bear with me. Many of you have written to the blog or my email disagreeing with my column, disagreeing specifically with my assertion the Niners never should have played Aldon Smith on Sunday. Some of you said it was the best thing for him to play. Some of you said I should get off my moral high horse. All of you were polite and I appreciate that. I hope you think what… Read More »
After the 49ers lost to the Colts yesterday, Jed York spoke to the media about Aldon Smith and why the team played him. “I don’t know that there’s a right decision in this situation,” he said. Wrong. There is a right decision if you want to make the right decision, if you actually care enough to take the time to think it through, if making the right decision matters to you. The decision to play Smith was blatantly wrong. It… Read More »
I keep reading and hearing from national media that the 49ers want Aldon Smith to get help — I guess for his drinking problem, not for his shooting problem. The national media is spinning this story favorably to the 49ers. I look at it a little differently. If the Niners are so vitally concerned Smith should get help they would have sent him wherever he needs to go on Friday. Why wait until Monday? He needs help immediately, not after… Read More »
Jim Harbaugh said today he expects Aldon Smith to play on Sunday. He also said discipline in these matters is up to the league. I wrote earlier Smith crashed on his way to practice. I want to amend that. I think he was on his way to practice at 7:00 a.m. I mean, where else would he being going? But who knows, he might have been sightseeing. Does Aldon Smith qualify as a role model?
Aldon Smith allegedly blew a .15 on his Breathalyzer test after crashing his car into a tree this morning, apparently on the way to work. The legal limit is .08, which means he was almost double the limit if reports are true.